Abstract
In an era characterized by the increasing complexity of products and the rapid turnover of the workforce across different companies, there is a growing need to invest significantly in quick and efficient training methods. Concurrently, the advancement of digitalization has rendered certain training practices anchored to paper-based materials obsolete. Numerous companies are directing their investments toward digital training, yet the optimal format to exploit the full advantages of digitalization remains unclear. This study undertakes a comparison of four distinct digital versions of the same training process with the aim of comprehending the tangible benefits. The findings indicate that to fully capitalize on the advantages of digital technology, a complete rethinking of training practices is necessary.
Graphical Abstract Figure
References
1.
De Weck
, O. L.
, Roos
, D.
, and Magee
, C. L.
, 2011
, Engineering Systems: Meeting Human Needs in a Complex Technological World
, MIT Press
, Cambridge, MA
.2.
Topcu
, T. G.
, Mukherjee
, S.
, Hennig
, A. I.
, and Szajnfarber
, Z.
, 2022
, “The Dark Side of Modularity: How Decomposing Problems Can Increase System Complexity
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 144
(3
), p. 031403. 3.
Serenko
, A.
, 2022
, “The Great Resignation: The Great Knowledge Exodus or the Onset of the Great Knowledge Revolution?
,” J. Knowl. Manag.
, 27
(4
), pp. 1042
–1055
. 4.
Sull
, D.
, Sull
, C.
, and Zweig
, B.
, 2022
, “Toxic Culture Is Driving the Great Resignation
,” MIT Sloan Manag. Rev.
, 63
(2
), pp. 1
–9
.5.
Salas
, E.
, and Cannon-Bowers
, J. A.
, 2001
, “The Science of Training: A Decade of Progress
,” Annu. Rev. Psychol.
, 52
(1
), pp. 471
–499
. 6.
Martin
, B. O.
, Kolomitro
, K.
, and Lam
, T. C. M.
, 2013
, “Training Methods
,” Hum. Resour. Dev. Rev.
, 13
(1
), pp. 11
–35
. 7.
Gegenfurtner
, A.
, Schmidt-Hertha
, B.
, and Lewis
, P.
, 2020
, “Digital Technologies in Training and Adult Education
,” Int. J. Train. Dev.
, 24
(1
), pp. 1
–4
. 8.
Allerton
, D.
, 2010
, “The Impact of Flight Simulation in Aerospace
,” Aeronaut. J.
, 114
(1162
), pp. 747
–756
. 9.
Pirker
, J.
, 2022
, “The Potential of Virtual Reality for Aerospace Applications
,” Proceedings of the 2022 IEEE Aerospace Conference (AERO)
, Big Sky, MT
, Mar. 5–12
, IEEE
, pp. 1
–8
.10.
Limongelli
, C.
, Mosiello
, G.
, Panzieri
, S.
, and Sciarrone
, F.
, 2012
, “Virtual Industrial Training: Joining Innovative Interfaces With Plant Modeling
,” Proceedings of the 2012 International Conference on Information Technology Based Higher Education and Training (ITHET)
, Istanbul, Turkey
, June 21–23
, IEEE
, pp. 1
–6
.11.
Xia
, K.
, Sacco
, C.
, Kirkpatrick
, M.
, Saidy
, C.
, Nguyen
, L.
, Kircaliali
, A.
, and Harik
, R.
, 2021
, “A Digital Twin to Train Deep Reinforcement Learning Agent for Smart Manufacturing Plants: Environment, Interfaces and Intelligence
,” J. Manuf. Syst.
, 58
, pp. 210
–230
. 12.
Zahabi
, M.
, and Razak
, A. M. A.
, 2020
, “Adaptive Virtual Reality-Based Training: A Systematic Literature Review and Framework
,” Virtual Real.
, 24
(4
), pp. 725
–752
. 13.
Vaughan
, N.
, Gabrys
, B.
, and Dubey
, V. N.
, 2016
, “An Overview of Self-Adaptive Technologies Within Virtual Reality Training
,” Comput. Sci. Rev.
, 22
, pp. 65
–87
. 14.
Aguayo
, C.
, and Eames
, C.
, 2023
, “Using Mixed Reality (XR) Immersive Learning to Enhance Environmental Education
,” J. Environ. Educ.
, 54
(1
), pp. 58
–71
. 15.
Reese
, H. W.
, 2011
, “The Learning-by-Doing Principle
,” Behav. Dev. Bull.
, 17
(1
), pp. 1
–19
. 16.
Dobbelstein
, D.
, Herrdum
, S.
, and Rukzio
, E.
, 2017
, “inScent
,” Proceedings of the 2017 ACM International Symposium on Wearable Computers, Association for Computing Machinery
, Maui, HI
, Sept. 11–15
, pp. 130
–137
.17.
Ghinea
, G.
, and Ademoye
, O.
, 2012
, “The Sweet Smell of Success
,” ACM Trans. Multimedia Comput. Commun. Appl.
, 8
(1
), pp. 1
–17
.18.
de Bruijn
, M. J.
, and Bender
, M.
, 2017
, “Olfactory Cues are More Effective Than Visual Cues in Experimentally Triggering Autobiographical Memories
,” Memory
, 26
(4
), pp. 547
–558
. 19.
Muller
, J.
, 2020
, “Enabling Technologies for Industry 5.0 – Results of a Workshop with Europe's Technology Leaders
,” European Commission, Directorate-General for Research and Innovation. https://data.europa.eu/doi/10.2777/08263420.
Schott
, C.
, and Marshall
, S.
, 2018
, “Virtual Reality and Situated Experiential Education: A Conceptualization and Exploratory Trial
,” J. Comput. Assist. Learn.
, 34
(6
), pp. 843
–852
. 21.
Fromm
, J.
, Radianti
, J.
, Wehking
, C.
, Stieglitz
, S.
, Majchrzak
, T. A.
, and vom Brocke
, J.
, 2021
, “More Than Experience?-On the Unique Opportunities of Virtual Reality to Afford a Holistic Experiential Learning Cycle
,” Internet High. Educ.
, 50
, p. 100804
. 22.
Trudeau
, A. A.
, 2020
, “Virtual Reality: Opening Doorways to Experiential Learning for Students
,” Proceedings of the 2020 Seventh International Conference on Information Technology Trends (ITT)
, Abu Dhabi, UAE
, Nov. 25–26
, IEEE
, pp. 80
–82
.23.
Kwon
, C.
, 2019
, “Verification of the Possibility and Effectiveness of Experiential Learning Using hmd-Based Immersive vr Technologies
,” Virtual Real.
, 23
(1
), pp. 101
–118
. 24.
Petersen
, G. B.
, Petkakis
, G.
, and Makransky
, G.
, 2022
, “A Study of How Immersion and Interactivity Drive vr Learning
,” Comput. Educ.
, 179
, p. 104429
. 25.
Cadet
, L. B.
, and Chainay
, H.
, 2020
, “Memory of Virtual Experiences: Role of Immersion, Emotion and Sense of Presence
,” Int. J. Hum. Comput. Stud.
, 144
, p. 102506
. 26.
Ochs
, C.
, and Sonderegger
, A.
, 2022
, “The Interplay Between Presence and Learning
,” Front. Virtual Real.
, 3
, p. 742509
. 27.
Liou
, W.-K.
, and Chang
, C.-Y.
, 2018
, “Virtual Reality Classroom Applied to Science Education
,” Proceedings of the 2018 23rd International Scientific-Professional Conference on Information Technology (IT)
, Turin, Italy
, Sept. 4–7
, IEEE
, pp. 1
–4
.28.
Ruthenbeck
, G. S.
, and Reynolds
, K. J.
, 2015
, “Virtual Reality for Medical Training: The State-of-the-Art
,” J. Simul.
, 9
(1
), pp. 16
–26
. 29.
Parmaxi
, A.
, 2020
, “Virtual Reality in Language Learning: A Systematic Review and Implications for Research and Practice
,” Interact. Learn. Environ.
, 31
(1
), pp. 172
–184
. 30.
Hickman
, L.
, and Akdere
, M.
, 2017
, “Exploring Virtual Reality for Developing Soft-Skills in STEM Education
,” Proceedings of the 2017 7th World Engineering Education Forum (WEEF)
, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
, Nov. 13–16
, IEEE
, pp. 461
–465
.31.
Zhu
, Y.
, and Li
, N.
, 2021
, “Virtual and Augmented Reality Technologies for Emergency Management in the Built Environments: A State-of-the-Art Review
,” J. Saf. Sci. Resil.
, 2
(1
), pp. 1
–10
. 32.
Harrison
, S. M.
, 1995
, “A Comparison of Still, Animated, or Nonillustrated On-Line Help With Written or Spoken Instructions in a Graphical User Interface
,” Proceedings of the SIGCHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems – CHI'95
, Denver, CO
, May 7–11
, ACM Press
, pp. 82
–89
.33.
Heiser
, J.
, Phan
, D.
, Agrawala
, M.
, Tversky
, B.
, and Hanrahan
, P.
, 2004
, “Identification and Validation of Cognitive Design Principles for Automated Generation of Assembly Instructions
,” Proceedings of the Working Conference on Advanced Visual Interfaces
, Gallipoli, Italy
, May 25–28
, ACM
, pp. 311
–319
.34.
Mayer
, R. E.
, Bove
, W.
, Bryman
, A.
, Mars
, R.
, and Tapangco
, L.
, 1996
, “When Less is More: Meaningful Learning From Visual and Verbal Summaries of Science Textbook Lessons
,” J. Educ. Psychol.
, 88
(1
), pp. 64
–73
. 35.
Prensky
, M.
, 2001
, “Digital Natives, Digital Immigrants Part 2: Do They Really Think Differently?
,” On Horizon
, 9
(6
), pp. 1
–6
. 36.
Bennett
, S.
, Maton
, K.
, and Kervin
, L.
, 2008
, “The ‘Digital Natives' Debate: A Critical Review of the Evidence
,” Br. J. Educ. Technol.
, 39
(5
), pp. 775
–786
. 37.
Ranasinghe
, N.
, Jain
, P.
, Thi Ngoc Tram
, N.
, Koh
, K. C. R.
, Tolley
, D.
, Karwita
, S.
, Lien-Ya
, L.
, et al, 2018
, “Season Traveller: Multisensory Narration for Enhancing the Virtual Reality Experience
,” Proceedings of the 2018 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems, CHI ’18
, Montreal, QC, Canada
, Apr. 21–26
, Association for Computing Machinery
, pp. 1
–13
.38.
Grabowski
, A.
, 2019
, “Innovative and Comprehensive Support System for Training People Working in Dangerous Conditions,” Digital Human Modeling and Applications in Health, Safety, Ergonomics and Risk Management. Human Body and Motion
, V. G.
Duffy
, ed., Springer International Publishing
, pp. 394
–405
.39.
Yigitbas
, E.
, Krois
, S.
, Renzelmann
, T.
, and Engels
, G.
, 2022
, “Comparative Evaluation of AR-Based, VR-Based, and Traditional Basic Life Support Training
,” Proceedings of the 2022 IEEE 10th International Conference on Serious Games and Applications for Health (SeGAH)
, Sydney, Australia
, Aug. 10–12
, IEEE
, pp. 1
–8
.40.
Kanade
, S. G.
, and Duffy
, V. G.
, 2022
, “Use of Virtual Reality for Safety Training: A Systematic Review,” Digital Human Modeling and Applications in Health, Safety, Ergonomics and Risk Management. Health, Operations Management, and Design
, V. G.
Duffy
, ed., Springer International Publishing
, pp. 364
–375
.41.
Bordegoni
, M.
, and Ferrise
, F.
, 2013
, “Designing Interaction With Consumer Products in a Multisensory Virtual Reality Environment
,” Virtual Phys. Prototyp.
, 8
(1
), pp. 51
–64
. 42.
Melo
, M.
, Goncalves
, G.
, Monteiro
, P.
, Coelho
, H.
, Vasconcelos-Raposo
, J.
, and Bessa
, M.
, 2022
, “Do Multisensory Stimuli Benefit the Virtual Reality Experience? A Systematic Review
,” IEEE Trans. Visual Comput. Graphics
, 28
(2
), pp. 1428
–1442
. 43.
Spence
, C.
, and Driver
, J.
, 2004
, Crossmodal Space and Crossmodal Attention
, Oxford University Press
, Oxford, UK
.44.
Nakamoto
, T.
, 2013
, Human Olfactory Displays and Interfaces
, IGI Global
, Hershey, PA
.45.
Porcherot
, C.
, Delplanque
, S.
, Raviot-Derrien
, S.
, Calvé
, B. L.
, Chrea
, C.
, Gaudreau
, N.
, and Cayeux
, I.
, 2010
, “How Do You Feel When You Smell This? Optimization of a Verbal Measurement of Odor-Elicited Emotions
,” Food Qual. Preference
, 21
(8
), pp. 938
–947
. 46.
Bordegoni
, M.
, and Carulli
, M.
, 2016
, “Evaluating Industrial Products in an Innovative Visual-Olfactory Environment
,” ASME J. Comput. Inf. Sci. Eng.
, 16
(3
), p. 030904
. 47.
Bordegoni
, M.
, Carulli
, M.
, Shi
, Y.
, and Ruscio
, D.
, 2017
, “Investigating the Effects of Odour Integration in Reading and Learning Experiences
,” ID&A Interact. Des. Archit.
, 32
, pp. 104
–125
. 48.
Yanagida
, Y.
, Kawato
, S.
, Noma
, H.
, Tomono
, A.
, and Tesutani
, N.
, 2004
, “Projection Based Olfactory Display with Nose Tracking
,” Proceedings of the IEEE Virtual Reality 2004
, Chicago, IL
, Mar. 27–31
, IEEE
, pp. 43
–50
.49.
Ghinea
, G.
, and Ademoye
, O. A.
, 2010
, “Olfaction-Enhanced Multimedia: Perspectives and Challenges
,” Multimed. Tools Appl.
, 55
(3
), pp. 601
–626
. 50.
Yanagida
, Y.
, 2012
, “A Survey of Olfactory Displays: Making and Delivering Scents
,” Proceedings of the 2012 IEEE Sensors
, Taipei, Taiwan
, Oct. 28–31
, IEEE
, pp. 1
–4
.51.
Bordegoni
, M.
, Carulli
, M.
, and Spadoni
, E.
, 2022
, “Multisensory Virtual Reality for Delivering Training Content to Machinery Operators
,” ASME J. Comput. Inf. Sci. Eng.
, 22
(3
), p. 031003
. 52.
Garcia-Ruiz
, M. A.
, Kapralos
, B.
, and Rebolledo-Mendez
, G.
, 2021
, “An Overview of Olfactory Displays in Education and Training
,” Multimodal Technol. Interact.
, 5
(10
), p. 64
. 53.
Olofsson
, J. K.
, Ekstrom
, I.
, Lindstrom
, J.
, Syrjanen
, E.
, Stigsdotter-Neely
, A.
, Nyberg
, L.
, Jonsson
, S.
, and Larsson
, M.
, 2020
, “Smell-Based Memory Training: Evidence of Olfactory Learning and Transfer to the Visual Domain
,” Chem. Senses
, 45
(7
), pp. 593
–600
. 54.
Klasnja-Milicevic
, A.
, Marosan
, Z.
, Ivanovic
, M.
, Savic
, N.
, and Vesin
, B.
, 2019
, “The Future of Learning Multisensory Experiences: Visual, Audio, Smell and Taste Senses
,” Proceedings of the 8th International Conference on Methodologies and Intelligent Systems for Technology Enhanced Learning
, Toledo, Spain
, June 20–22
, T.
Di Mascio
, P.
Vittorini
, R.
Gennari
, F.
De la Prieta
, S.
Rodrıguez
, V.
Temperini
, R.
Azambuja Silveira
, E.
Popescu
, and L.
Lancia
, eds., Springer International Publishing
, pp. 213
–221
.55.
Van Toller
, C. S.
, and Dodd
, G. H.
, 1993
, Fragrance: The Psychology and Biology of Perfume
, Springer-Verlag New York, LLC
, New York, US
.56.
Raudenbush
, B.
, Grayhem
, R.
, Sears
, T.
, and Wilson
, I.
, 2009
, “Effects of Peppermint and Cinnamon Odor Administration on Simulated Driving Alertness, Mood and Workload
,” N. Am. J. Psychol.
, 11
(2
), pp. 245
–245
.57.
Rossoni
, M.
, Carulli
, M.
, Bordegoni
, M.
, and Colombo
, G.
, 2022
, “Prototyping of an Olfactory Display Supported by CFD Simulations
,” Comput.-Aided Des. Applic.
, 20
(1
), pp. 174
–189
. 58.
Lukasiewicz
, M. S.
, Rossoni
, M.
, Spadoni
, E.
, Dozio
, N.
, Carulli
, M.
, Ferrise
, F.
, and Bordegoni
, M.
, 2023
, “An Open-Source Olfactory Display to Add the Sense of Smell to the Metaverse
,” ASME J. Comput. Inf. Sci. Eng.
, 24
(2
), p. 024501
. 59.
Winterbottom
, D.
, and Wagenfeld
, A.
, 2015
, Therapeutic Gardens: Design for Healing Spaces
, Timber Press
, Portland, OR
.60.
Herz
, R.
, 2009
, The Scent of Desire: Discovering our Enigmatic Sense of Smell
, Harper Collins
.61.
Brooke
, J.
, 1996
, “SUS: a “Quick and Dirty” Usability Scale,” Usability Evaluation in Industry
, Vol. 3
, P. W.
Jordan
, B.
Thomas
, B. A.
Weerdmeester
, and A. L.
McClelland
, eds., Taylor and Francis Ltd.
, Earley, UK
, pp. 189
–194
.62.
Hart
, S. G.
, and Staveland
, L. E.
, 1988
, “Development of NASA-TLX (Task Load Index): Results of Empirical and Theoretical Research,” Advances in Psychology
, Elsevier
, New York
, pp. 139
–183
.63.
Hart
, S. G.
, 2006
, “Nasa-Task Load Index (NASA-TLX); 20 Years Later
,” Proc. Hum. Factors Ergon. Soc. Annu. Meet.
, 50
(9
), pp. 904
–908
. 64.
Bradley
, M. M.
, and Lang
, P. J.
, 1994
, “Measuring Emotion: The Self-Assessment Manikin and the Semantic Differential
,” J. Behav. Ther. Exp. Psychiatry
, 25
(1
), pp. 49
–59
. 65.
Kennedy
, R. S.
, Lane
, N. E.
, Berbaum
, K. S.
, and Lilienthal
, M. G.
, 1993
, “Simulator Sickness Questionnaire: An Enhanced Method for Quantifying Simulator Sickness
,” Int. J. Aviat. Psychol.
, 3
(3
), pp. 203
–220
. 66.
Witmer
, B. G.
, Jerome
, C. J.
, and Singer
, M. J.
, 2005
, “The Factor Structure of the Presence Questionnaire
,” Presence
, 14
(3
), pp. 298
–312
. 67.
Tsai
, E. Y.-T.
, and Hsieh
, D.
, 2012
, “Smellware: Olfactory Feedback for Code Smell in Software Development
,” Proceedings of the Human Interface Technologies 2011/12 Fall Conference
, Orlando, FL
, July 9–14
, pp. 1
–6
.68.
Alkasasbeh
, A. A.
, and Ghinea
, G.
, 2020
, “Using Olfactory Media Cues in e-Learning – Perspectives From an Empirical Investigation
,” Multimed. Tools Appl.
, 79
(27–28
), pp. 19265
–19287
. 69.
Bordegoni
, M.
, and Ferrise
, F.
, 2023
, “Exploring the Intersection of Metaverse, Digital Twins, and Artificial Intelligence in Training and Maintenance
,” ASME J. Comput. Inf. Sci. Eng.
, 23
(6
), p. 060806
. 
