The idea of using a bed-of-pins as a completely reconfigurable discrete tool surface (referred to as a reconfigurable pin-type tool) for forming or molding of mechanical components has been around for at least . Interestingly, the state-of-the-art today differs little from early patents except for the introduction of powered actuation and computer control. To help explain why this promising manufacturing technology is not used more extensively in industry, this paper attempts to tell a complete story about reconfigurable pin-type tooling through analysis of the state-of-the-art academic and industrial research, and commercialization of the concept from the original patented concept in 1863. The authors begin by defining what a reconfigurable tool is and by describing what characteristics an ideal reconfigurable tool should have. Next, the history of reconfigurable tooling patents from 1863 to 2003 and related research from the late 1960s to the present is recounted. One major research effort that eventually led to the development of a commercial project was the U.S. government-sponsored Reconfigurable Tooling for Flexible Fabrication project. A critical analysis shows that the state-of-the-art in reconfigurable pin-type tooling meets all specifications of the defined “ideal tool” with the exception of spatial resolution and weight. Finally, the reserved response by industry to adopt reconfigurable pin-type tooling and future of reconfigurable tooling is discussed.
Issue Section:
Technical Papers
1.
Fleming
, W.
, 1987, “Vertical Three-Dimensional Image Screen
,” U.S. Patent No. 4,654,989, issued April 7.2.
Can You Imagine website: http://www.cyi.net/http://www.cyi.net/, accessed on January 2006.
3.
Sillery
, B.
, 2002, “The Everything Contraption: Building a Die That Builds All
,” Pop. Sci. (U.S.)
0161-7370, 260
(6
), p. 41
.4.
Hardt
, D. E.
, Boyce
, M. C.
, Ousterhout
, K. B.
, and Karafillis
, A.
, 1992, “A Flexible Forming System for Sheet Metal
,” Proc, NSF Conference on Design and Manufacturing Systems Research
, Jan., pp. 77
–86
.5.
Kleespies
, H. S.
, and Crawford
, R. H.
, 1998, “Vacuum Forming of Compound Curved Surfaces With a Variable Geometry Mold
,” J. Manuf. Syst.
0278-6125, 17
(5
), pp. 325
–337
.6.
Finckenstein
, E. V.
, and Kleiner
, M.
, 1991, “Flexible Numerically Controlled Tool System for Hydro-Mechanical Deep Drawing
,” CIRP Ann.
0007-8506, 40
(1
), pp. 311
–314
(in German).7.
Eigen
, G. F.
, 1992, “Smoothing Methods for Discrete Die Forming
,” M.S. thesis, Department of Mechanical Engineering, M.I.T.8.
Walczyk
, D. F.
, Hosford
, J.
, and Papazian
, J.
, 2003, “Using Reconfigurable Tooling and Surface Heating for Incremental Forming of Composite Aircraft Parts
,” ASME J. Manuf. Sci. Eng.
1087-1357, 25
(2
), pp. 333
–343
.9.
Prabhakara
, R.
, 2002, “Incremental Forming of Thermoset Composite Lay-ups Using Active Tooling
,” M.S. thesis, Department of Mechanical, Aerospace & Nuclear Engineering, Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute.10.
Munro
, C. B.
, Walczyk
, D. F.
, Dvorak
, G.
, and Slusarski
, S.
, 2004, “Incremental Double Diaphragm Forming of Composite Materials Using Reconfigurable Tooling
,” Proceedings of 2004 SME North American Manufacturing Research Conference (NAMRC)
, Charlotte, NC
.11.
Cochrane
, J.
, 1863, “Bending Metal Plates
,” U.S. Patent No. 39,886, issued September 15.12.
Ansted
, E. W.
, 1892, “Machine for Bending and Forming Springs
,” U.S. Patent No. 483,094, issued September 20.13.
Elkins
, L. F.
, 1920, “Die for Spring Forming Machines
,” U.S. Patent No. 1,331,630, issued February 24.14.
Williams
, C. J.
, and Skinner
, T.
, 1923, “Spring Forming Device
,” U.S. Patent No. 1,465,152, issued August 14.15.
Tegarden
, J. E.
, 1957, “Forming Machine
,” U.S. Patent No. 2,783,815, issued March 5.16.
Morita
, M.
, 1993, “Leaf Spring Cambering Method and Apparatus
,” U.S. Patent No. 5,187,969, issued February 23.17.
O’Kelley
, J. F.
, 1945, “Hood and Fender Jig
,” U.S. Patent No. 2,446,487, issued August 3.18.
Walters
, T.
, 1943, “Press
,” U.S. Patent No. 2,334,520, issued November 16.19.
Pinson
, G. T.
, 1980, “Apparatus for Forming Sheet Metal
,” U.S. Patent No. 4,212,188, issued July 15.20.
Fuchs
, A.
, Radolfzellerstr
, L. L.
, and Konstanz
, D. E.
, 1982, “Method and Arrangement for Producing a Curved Sail
,” U.S. Patent No. 4,309,824, issued January 12.21.
Kommineni
, P.
, Hollandsworth
, P. E.
, and Jones
, J. W.
, 1988, “Method of Shaping an Antenna Panel
,” U.S. Patent No. 4,731,144, issued March 15.22.
Sherrill
, D. E.
, and Young
, K. G.
, 2001, “Apparatus for Constructing a Composite Structure
,” U.S. Patent No. 6,298,896 B1, issued October 9.23.
Sherrill
, D. E.
, and Young
, K. G.
, 2004, “Method for Constructing a Composite Structure
,” U.S. Patent No. 6,761,785 B2, issued July 13.24.
Hoffman
, P. L.
, and Florissant
, M. O.
, 1998, “Reconfigurable Modular Tooling System
,” U.S. Patent No. 5,851,563, issued December 22.25.
Hess
, F.
, 1931, “Process and Apparatus for Manufacturing Automatically Accurate Individual Foot Supports for Shoes
,” U.S. Patent No. 1,826,783, issued October 13.26.
Trudell
, C. P.
, 1942, “Sheet Metal Forming Apparatus
,” U.S. Patent No. 2,280,359, issued April 21.27.
Humphrey
, D. H.
, 1971, “Mold Forming Device
,” U.S. Patent No. 3,596,869, issued August 3.28.
Bernardon
, E.
, and Foley
, M. F.
, 1992, “Reconfigurable Fiber-Forming Resin Transfer System
,” U.S. Patent No. 5,151,277, issued September 29.29.
Hoffman
, P. L.
, and Florissant
, M. O.
, 1992, “Conformable Tool
,” U.S. Patent No. 5,168,635, issued December 8.30.
Umetsu
, S.
, and Toshihiko
, M.
, 1993, “Variable Mold Apparatus
,” U.S. Patent No. 5,192,560, issued March 9.31.
Haas
, E. G.
, and Kesselman
, M.
, 1996, “Adjustable Form Die
,” U.S. Patent No. 5,546,784, issued August 20.32.
Sullivan
, E. V.
, Haas
, E. G.
, Schwarz
, R. C.
, Kesselman
, M.
, Peck
, A. N.
, and Papazian
, J. M.
, 2000, “Individual Motor Pin Module
,” U.S. Patent No. 6,012,314, issued January 11.33.
Nardiello
, J. A.
, Christ
, R. J.
, and Papazian
, J. M.
, 2000, “Block-Set Form Die Assembly
,” U.S. Patent No. 6,053,026, issued April 25.34.
Haas
, E. G.
, Schwarz
, R. C.
, and Papazian
, J. M.
, 2000, “Modularized, Reconfigurable Heated Forming Tool
,” U.S. Patent No. 6,089,061, issued July 18.35.
Papazian
, J. M.
, Haas, E. G., Schwarz
, R. C.
, Nardiello
, J. A.
, and Melnichuk
, J.
, 2001, “Pin Tip Assembly in Tooling Apparatus for Forming Honeycomb Cores
,” U.S. Patent No. 6,209,380, issued April 3.36.
Papazian
, J. M.
, Nardiello
, J. A.
, Schwarz
, R. C.
, and Melnichuk
, J.
, 2002, “System and Method for Forming Sheet Metal Using a Reconfigurable Tool
,” U.S. Patent No. 6,363,767, issued April 2.37.
Meilunas
, R. J.
, Dillon
, G. P.
, and Nardiello
, J. A.
, 2002, “System for Constructing a Laminate
,” U.S. Patent No. 6,484,776, issued November 26.38.
Haas
, E. G.
, Schwarz
, R. C.
, and Papazian
, J. M.
, 2003, “Single-Die Modularized, Reconfigurable Honeycomb Core Forming Tool
,” U.S. Patent No. 6,578,399, issued June 17.39.
Berteau
, J.
, 1994, “Variable-Shape Mold
,” U.S. Patent No. 5,330,343, issued July 19.40.
Schroeder
, T.
, and Stevenson
, R.
, 1996, “Surface Generating Device Suitable for Generating a Die, Mold or Fixture Surface
,” U.S. Patent No. 5,513,972, issued May 7.41.
Schroeder
, T.
, and Stevenson
, R.
, 1998, “Device for Generating a Fixture
,” U.S. Patent No. 5,738,345, issued April 14.42.
Wakefield
, W. H.
, 1943, “Die and Method of Making Same
,” U.S. Patent No. 2,332,360, issued October 19.43.
Hicks
, A. A.
, 1961, “Three-Dimensional Die
,” U.S. Patent No. 2,968,838, issued January 24.44.
Whitacre
, F. E.
, 1971, “Incremental Die Construction Having a Hole Piercing Capability
,” U.S. Patent No. 3,559,450, issued February 2.45.
Todoroki
, M.
, Imazu
, H.
, Nomura
, H.
, Yamaguchi
, N.
, Zama
, J. A.
, Ishibashi
, K.
, and Yamamoto
, K.
, 1993, “Apparatus and Method for Producing Variable Configuration Die
,” U.S. Patent No. 5,253,176, issued October 12.46.
Hong
, K.
, 1994, “Modeling Mechanism
,” U.S. Patent No. 5,281,117, issued January 25.47.
Laskowski
, J. S.
, and Pintz
, A.
, 1998, “Computerized System For Lost Foam Casting Process Using Rapid Tooling Set-Up
,” U.S. Patent No. 5,796,620, issued August 18.48.
Nakajima
, N.
, 1969, “A Newly Developed Technique to Fabricate Complicated Dies and Electrodes With Wires
,” Bull. JSME
0021-3764, 12
(54
), pp. 1546
–1554
.49.
Wolak
, J.
, Bodoia
, J. R.
, and Sherrer
, R. E.
, 1973, “A Preliminary Study of an Infinitely Variable Surface Generator and its Application to Die Forming
,” Manuf. Eng. Trans.
0363-700X, II
, pp. 155
–160
.50.
Wright
, P. K.
, and Holzer
, A. J.
, 1981, “A Programmable Die for the Powder Metallurgy Process
,” Proceedings of NAMRC
, 9
, pp. 65
–70
.51.
Owodunni
, O. O.
, Diaz-Rozo
, J.
, and Hinduja
, S.
, 2004, “Development and Evaluation of a Low-Cost Computer Controlled Reconfigurable Rapid Tool
,” Comput.-Aided Des. Appl.
, 1
(1–4
), pp. 101
–108
.52.
Hardt
, D. E.
, and Gossard
, D. C.
, 1980, “A Variable Geometry Die for Sheet Metal Forming: Machine Design and Control
,” Proc. Joint Automatic Control Conference
, August.53.
Hardt
, D. E.
, Olson
, B. A.
, Allison
, B. T.
, and Pasch
, K.
, 1981, “Sheet Metal Forming With Discrete Die Surfaces
,” Ninth North American Manufacturing Research Conference Proceedings
, May, pp. 140
–144
.54.
Hardt
, D. E.
, and Webb
, R. D.
, 1982, “Sheet Metal Die Forming Using Closed-Loop Shape Control
,” CIRP Ann.
0007-8506, 31
, pp. 165
–169
.55.
Hardt
, D. E.
, Webb
, R. D.
, and Robinson
, R. E.
, 1985, “Closed-Loop Control of Die Stamped Sheet Metal Parts: Algorithm Development and Flexible Forming Machine Design
,” Proc. Advanced Systems for Manufacturing Conference
, May, pp. 21
–28
.56.
Webb
, R. D.
, and Hardt
, D. E.
, 1991, “A Transfer Function Description of Sheet Metal Forming for Process Control
,” ASME J. Eng. Ind.
0022-0817, 113
, p. 44
.57.
Hardt
, D. E.
, Boyce
, M. C.
, Ousterhout
, K. B.
, Sim
, H. B.
, and Karafillis
, A.
, 1992, “Closed-Loop Control of Sheet Metal Forming Process: Controller Analysis and Three Dimensional Experiments
,” Proc, NSF Conference on Design and Manufacturing Systems Research
, January, 1991.58.
Walczyk
, D. F.
, and Hardt
, D. E.
, 1998, “Design and Analysis of Reconfigurable Discrete Dies for Sheet Metal Forming
,” J. Manuf. Syst.
0278-6125, 17
(6
), pp. 436
–454
.59.
Walczyk
, D. F.
, and Hardt
, D. E.
, 1999, “A Comparison of Rapid Fabrication Methods for Sheet Metal Forming Dies
,” ASME J. Manuf. Sci. Eng.
1087-1357, 121
, pp. 214
–224
.60.
Walczyk
, D. F.
, Lakshmikanthan
, J.
, and Kirk
, D. R.
, 1998, “Development of a Reconfigurable Tool for Forming of Aircraft Panels
,” J. Manuf. Syst.
0278-6125, 17
(4
), pp. 287
–296
.61.
Im
, Y.
, Walczyk
, D. F.
, Schwarz
, R. C.
, and Papazian
, J. M.
, 2000, “A Comparison of Pin Actuation Schemes for Large-Scale Discrete Dies
,” J. Manuf. Process.
1526-6125, 2
(4
), pp. 247
–257
.62.
Cyril Bath Company website, 2005, http://www.cyrilbath.comhttp://www.cyrilbath.com.
63.
Papazian
, J. M.
, 2002, “Tools of Change: Reconfigurable Forming Dies Raise the Efficiency of Small-Lot Production
,” Mech. Eng. (Am. Soc. Mech. Eng.)
0025-6501, 124
(2
), pp. 52
–55
.64.
North Sails North America website, 2005, http://na.northsails.com/http://na.northsails.com/.
65.
Huntsman Advanced Materials website: http://www.huntsman.com/advanced_materials/Media/2005-05-03ChinaCar(UK).pdfhttp://www.huntsman.com/advanced_materials/Media/2005-05-03ChinaCar(UK).pdf, accessed on October 2006.
66.
Surface Generation website: http://www.surface-generation.comhttp://www.surface-generation.com, accessed on December 2006.
67.
Haas
, E.
, Schwarz
, R.
, and Papazian
, J.
, 2002, “Design and Test of a Reconfigurable Forming Die
,” J. Manuf. Process.
1526-6125, 4
(1
), pp. 77
–85
.68.
Boas
, R. C.
, 1997, “Sequential Setup Mechanism Design for a Reconfigurable Sheet Metal Forming Die
,” M.S. thesis, Department of Mechanical Engineering, M.I.T.69.
Maxon Precision Motor, Inc.
website: http://www.maxonmotorusa.com/http://www.maxonmotorusa.com/, accessed on September 2006.70.
Gladwell
, M.
, 2002, The Tipping Point: How Little Things Can Make a Big Difference
, Little, Brown & Co.
, New York
.Copyright © 2007
by American Society of Mechanical Engineers
You do not currently have access to this content.
